Condoms sometimes permissible to stop AIDS-Pope

Sun Nov 21, 2010 10:05am GMT
 

By Philip Pullella

VATICAN CITY (Reuters) - Using condoms may sometimes be justified to stop the spread of AIDS, Pope Benedict says in a new book, in a major shift that relaxes one of the Vatican's most controversial positions on their use to combat the disease.

The pope's words in the book to be published on Tuesday -- while limited in scope and which do not change the Catholic ban on contraception -- were nonetheless greeted as a breakthrough by dissident Catholics, AIDS workers and commentators.

"It is a marvellous victory for common sense and reason, a major step forward towards recognising that condom use can play a vital role in reducing the future impact of the HIV pandemic, said Jon O'Brien, head of the U.S. group Catholics for Choice.

In the 219-page book, "Light of the World," the pope also speaks frankly about the possibility that he could resign for health reasons and defends wartime pontiff Pius XII against Jewish accusations that he turned a blind eye to the Holocaust.

He says scandals of sexual abuse of minors by priests. were "an unprecedented shock," even though he had followed the issue for years, and says he can understand why people might quit the Church in protest.

But it is the section on condoms in the book -- a long interview with German Catholic journalist Peter Seewald -- that marked a crack in the once tightly shut door of Church policy.

He cites the example of the use of condoms by prostitutes as "a first step towards moralisation," even though condoms are "not really the way to deal with the evil of HIV infection."

The original German text and the French and English versions of the book refer to a male prostitute but an excerpt in Italian in the Vatican newspaper uses female prostitute.

PAPAL FIRST

While some Roman Catholic leaders have spoken about the limited use of condoms to stop the spread of HIV/AIDS as the lesser of two evils, this is the first time the pope has mentioned the possibility.

The leading Italian newspaper Corriere della Sera said the time was "ripe" for such a papal opening and even the conservative Il Giornale ran an opinion story headlined: "We are all sinners, the Church cannot be made of stone."

Benedict made clear the comments were not intended to weaken the Church's fundamental opposition to artificial birth control, a source of grievance to many Catholics.

Last year, the pope caused an international uproar when he told journalists accompanying him to Africa that condoms should not be used because they could worsen the spread of AIDS.

He says that the "sheer fixation on the condom implies a banalisation of sexuality" where this is no longer an expression of love "but only a sort of drug that people administer to themselves."

The Church had been saying for decades that condoms are not even part of the solution to fighting AIDS, even though no formal position on this existed in a Vatican document.

The late cardinal John O'Connor of New York famously branded the use of condoms to stop the spread of AIDS as "The Big Lie."

After the pope first mentions that the use of condoms could be justified in certain limited cases, such as by prostitutes, Seewald asks: "Are you saying, then, that the Catholic Church is actually not opposed in principle to the use of condoms?"

The pope answers: "It of course does not regard it as a real or moral solution, but, in this or that case, there can be nonetheless, in the intention of reducing the risk of infection, a first step in a movement towards a different way, a more human way, of living sexuality."

REALITY CHECK

Act Up Paris, an AIDS support group, said: "After having said that condoms make the AIDS epidemic worse, after getting involved in questions he has no expertise on, the pope seems to finally be taking account of the principle of reality."

The Vatican's opposition to artificial birth control has been highly contested, even by many Catholics, since it was formalised in the late Pope Paul's encyclical Humanae Vitae (On Human Life) in 1968.

Benedict says that "the basic lines of Humanae Vitae are still correct," indicating that his comments about condoms are not intended to apply to birth control, only to AIDS prevention.

In the section of the book on condoms and HIV/AIDS, the pope goes as far as mentioning the "ABC principle" (Abstinence-Be faithful-Condom) on preventing the spread of AIDS.

While he says ABC was developed in "the secular realm," he uses the example himself to introduce his own comments on condoms being sometimes justified as a last resort.

Critics have said it took many years for the Church to realise that AIDS was not just a disease of the homosexual community and that many heterosexual women, particularly in Africa, were being killed.

Gerard Guerin, secretary general of Christians and AIDS group in France, said the pope had not gone far enough.

"The pope's statements are convoluted. It's limited to cite only the case of male prostitutes. What are couples with one infected partner supposed to do?" he told Le Parisien newspaper.

(Writing by Philip Pullella; additional reporting by Tom Heneghan in Paris; editing by Myra MacDonald)

<p>A member of the No To Pope Coalition displays a condom on her thumb during a media call in Sydney in this July 4, 2008 file photo. REUTERS/Daniel Munoz/Files</p>
 
Powered by Reuters AlertNet. AlertNet provides news, images and insight from the world's disasters and conflicts and is brought to you by Reuters Foundation.